You are reading

Queens is “Missing” From L Train Shutdown Mitigation Plan, Activist Group Says

Court Square (Access Queens)

Dec. 15, 2017 By Nathaly Pesantez

The recently-released L Train mitigation plan, which outlines preliminary strategies for rerouting thousands of the line’s riders once the tunnel closes for repairs, has Queens “missing from its pages”, according to a local activist group.

Access Queens, the transit advocate group most known for their 7 Train Blues campaign, said the joint plan by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and the Department of Transportation overlooks Queens, which is slated to see immense changes in 2019, when the Canarsie Tunnel shuts down for 15 months worth of Superstorm Sandy repairs.

The long-awaited mitigation plan, released on Dec. 13, includes detailed and ambitious plans for lower Manhattan, like making 14th Street bus only. A proposal to make the Williamsburg Bridge HOV-3 only during rush hours is also included, along with major changes to a throughway in Williamsburg and Bushwick.

Details on plans for western Queens, however, have been sparse, with plans to bring unspecified improvements to the Court Square station and free transfers at 21 St/Hunters Point Avenue.

The lack of attention given to Queens in the proposal, when 80 percent of the L train’s 400,000 daily riders are expected to use lines like the G train to connect to the Manhattan-linking Court Square, are concerning for the transit group.

“Only part of the story is told, focusing solely on the impact in Brooklyn and Manhattan,” writes Melissa Orlando, founder of Access Queens, in a Dec. 15 letter. “The addition of thousands of riders to overcrowded lines such as the 7 and the E trains is a disaster waiting to happen.”

Access Queens says the preliminary plans fail to offer additional service at the Court Square station, especially as G train ridership is expected to grow “dramatically” with the train increasing its length by four cars. The group also criticized the MTA and DOT for only considering some of the solutions outlined in their report, titled “L Train Shutdown ‘Crowd Calming’ Options”, sent to the MTA months ago.

Only two of the solutions outlined by Access Queens, which included extending the G line further into Queens, new bus options, and free walking transfers, all to decrease the risks that come with overcrowding, were included in the joint mitigation plan.

“Will the city work with the MTA to place additional police personnel at Court Square in order to prevent serious incidents, like harassment and fights that break out frequently on overcrowded lines?” part of Access Queens’ letter reads. “Who will ensure riders are safe while they wait for trains on packed platforms?”

The crowd calming options report was also pushed forth by Assemblywoman Cathy Nolan, who wrote to Joseph Lhota, the MTA chairman, urging him to look into the “helpful” solutions to mitigate the effects of the shutdown on western Queens in a November letter.

The mitigation plan comes days after the Court Square Civic Association (CSCA) sent a letter to Lhota also pushing for the agency to consider Access Queens’ solutions, especially in light of the rapid growth and development in Long Island City.

“We are already experiencing long lines on the platform approaches and hazardous platform crowding during rush hour,” wrote Pedro Gomez, president of the CSCA, in his Dec. 6 letter. Gomez added that the Court Square station saw a 25 percent increase in ridership from 2011 to 2016.

Both Nolan and Access Queens are calling for more public meetings in the borough to learn about the impact of the tunnel shutdown.

“We hope the MTA will hear riders’ concerns and develop additional strategies to accommodate riders whose commutes will be rerouted through Queens,” Orlando wrote in the letter.

The MTA and DOT said community meetings to present plans and receive community input will begin starting January 2018.

L Train Shutdown Access Queens by Queens Post on Scribd

email the author: [email protected]


Click for Comments 

Oh my Lordy, I take the E at Court Square every day and it’s duper crowded at present. I foresee double if not triple the mass of commuters when the L shuts down?. And I’m on the platform at 6:10 am and it’s so crazy! Yes they need to extend the G line as once before.


Seems like the most common sense solution is to extend the G on the local track to 179th Street. 179th always had the track capacity and help with the demand along Archer Avenue, the MTA could send the M to Jamaica Center along with the E line.


Please extend the G line further into Queens! That transfer at Court Square between the G, E and 7 is so overcrowded it’s scary and dangerous!

ray frederick

yes the L shutdown will impact queens and if you think that’s bad wait until you see the impact of all these new buildings opening in 2018 in LIC! lots of new buildings but still the same old broken trains! all those people how will they get to manhattan!? yeah sandy was nasty but mayor bloomberg and the real estate barons are even worse!!!


All the other boroughs are stepchildren of Manhattan. Run the G into Queens 71 Continental already!!!!!!!!!


In addition to all these problems, there are accessibility problems to consider. The MTA missed an important opportunity to install an elevator to the G platform at Court Square–they just finished renovating four staircases, which is nice, but there are no wheelchair-accessible stations along the G line until you get to Bergen (to transfer on the same platform to the F–still no elevator). The only elevator on the entire line is at Church Ave.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Op-ed: An urgent call for revising NY’s criminal justice reforms to protect public safety

Apr. 11, 2024 By Council Member Robert Holden

In 2019, the State Legislature and Governor Andrew Cuomo embarked on a controversial overhaul of New York’s criminal justice system by enacting several laws, including cashless bail and sweeping changes to discovery laws. Simultaneously, the New York City Council passed laws that compounded these challenges, notably the elimination of punitive segregation in city jails and qualified immunity for police officers. These actions have collectively undermined public safety and constrained law enforcement effectiveness.