You are reading

Council Members to Introduce Bill Blocking Hush City Dealings in Corporate Bids After Amazon HQ2

Existing Anable Basin waterfront, where Amazon will move into (Plaxall)

Nov. 30, 2018 By Nathaly Pesantez

A group of council members are set to introduce legislation soon that they say will help prevent “backroom deals” like the one that brought the controversial Amazon HQ2 project to Long Island City.

The bill, backed by Council Members Jimmy Van Bramer, Jumaane Williams and Brad Lander, would bar the city from participating in corporate bidding processes that require non-disclosure agreements, or NDAs, as was the case with HQ2 proceedings.

The hush negotiations are one component to the tremendous backlash over Amazon’s recently-announced headquarters in Long Island City, but have proved to be a major flashpoint for opponents of the plan.

The secret dealings leading up to Amazon’s decision, opponents say, were a way for the city and state to keep the public—including local officials—in the dark in order to push the deal through as quickly as possible.

Valuable input, they add, could have been given at the local level to push for a better deal—if negotiations with the company weren’t private.

“This piece of legislation is going to go a long way to making sure that democracy doesn’t get shelved in the future,” said Van Bramer, one of the central opponents to the Amazon project.

He added: “Transparency should be the minimum requirement when you’re talking about shelving out billions of dollars in taxpayers money.”

The three lawmakers said in their announcement yesterday that their bill would have changed the course of the controversial HQ2 proceedings with the city if it had already been in place.

“…The city would have had to say to Amazon, ‘You’ve got two choices—we can tell the public what our bid looks like, or we won’t be able to bid’,” Lander said to reporters.

The bill follows a similar piece of legislation set to go through Albany and introduced by State Sen. Michael Gianaris, another vocal opponent of the Amazon deal.

Along with the bill’s introduction comes plans for oversight hearings within the City Council over Amazon HQ2 proceedings. The hearings, according to reports, will take place over the course of several months beginning in December, with high-ranking city officials like Alicia Glen, deputy mayor, and James Patchett, CEO of the Economic Development Corporation, invited.

“New Yorkers deserve to know the fine details of the closed-door negotiations that led to this corporate giveaway,” Van Bramer said about the hearings.

Amazon’s HQ2 announcement came with the release of the memorandum of agreement it reached with the city and state, which detailed must-haves and other parameters related to its upcoming 4 million square foot headquarter build-out.

Components of the agreement, reached only after talks between a select few city, state, and Amazon players, include promised job output numbers, commitments to infrastructure improvements, and provisions for open space, a school, and more at the Anable Basin headquarter site.

The deal also lays out state and city subsidies for the company, set at a current $1.5 billion, with other government programs, credits and incentives possibly pushing the number to around $3 billion.

In response to criticism about its secretive proceedings, city and state officials say it had been made clear many months before the HQ2 announcement that negotiations would have to be done behind closed doors. Private talks, they say, are essential to maintaining competitiveness in a large project.

City and state officials also said that the only secretive component of the deal were the negotiations leading up to it, and that now begins a “very public conversation” on Amazon’s campus, including its design and build-out.

“A lot of folks have reacted to this thinking that this is a fully designed project,” Patchett said during a media briefing last week. “The truth of the matter is it’s not.”

email the author:


Click for Comments 
Gardens Watcher

Don’t remember the same level of outrage about the proposed development of Sunnyside Yard.


Jimmy Van Bramer is a useless flip flopping politician.
A year ago he was in favor of Amazon and today he is against it. This guy will do anything for the spotlight.


Wow…JVB is still at this? I guess he hasn’t gotten his bag of cash for supporting the deal yet. Hell hath no fury like a developer’s lapdog scorned.


Private riparian rights are subordinate to the public trust doctrine.
If the comic book character requirement of a private heliport is to be pandered to, it can be placed on the roof of HQ2. Let the taxpayers enjoy the waterfront.

Gardens Watcher

Been to that part of the waterfront? It’s an eyesore. Nothing for the public to enjoy there right now, unlike the area just to the south.

A Parent

Will the promised school be located and zoned to be used by current local residents? Who will pay for the training and employment of school personnel and for building maintenance?

Alma de Cubano

Our leaders need to have all the information up front. That way they can buy land and benefit the next time Cuomo gives his “contributors” the benefit of “the doubt!”

Doesn’t this corruption piss you off?


This back room dealing should have been stopped a LONG TIME AGO. New York voters are some of the DUMBEST people on earth to keep electing the same CROOKS into office and expect CHANGE. New York State is the most corrupt state in the USA-FACT. Is it a coincidence DUMB-O-CRATS run it? I Don’t think so.


Yeah who could be dumb enough to vote for someone as corrupt as Trump?

Remember when he pretended he wasn’t building a Trump Tower in Russia during the 2016 election. Oops, that was a lie! You’d never be gullible enough to vote for someone THAT corrupt right?


“The only secretive component of this were the negotiations…” is the line in the well reported item, above, that sticks. And stinks.
This story implies the State, especially, was shelling out our taxes in a promise for the heady “victory” of landing the Amazon big fish. A dozen Walmarts worth of crud, including naming rights to one governor, “Amazon Cuomo.” Bezos and company is a stinking mess about to land on our Queens waterfront, and our elected heads traded a waterfront location, ripe for a helicopter landing pad for Bezos personal use, with guest status for governors and mayors, likely, and industrial zoning, one huge Department of Education supply and training building employing 1,00 or more civil servants, most union members, for the heady victory of winning. (The DOE building is huge, flanked by the Sandy flooded area and 44th Drive.)
Many other locations were better suited. But two better suckers than these two were unavailable.


Wait! Jimmy Van Bramer is only envious and he was cut out of the Amazon HQ deal – not even notified until after it was announced. Hey Jimmy how about supporting affordable housing FOR THE WORKING POOR on Barnett Ave in the Steve Madden Parking Lot on your side of blvd.


How about affordable housing options for everyone starting with rent regulation on all apartments.

Bs. Vote out jvb

It’s all political posturing. Our constituents are mad and feel like we hid things from them. Quick, let’s tell them we were in the dark too and make a stink.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

AG James announces dismantling of Queens-based ghost gun trafficking operation

New York Attorney General Letitia James announced Wednesday the takedown of a prolific Queens-based gun trafficking crew accused of selling firearms and ammo at an East Elmhurst playground, the Queens Center Mall and other locations around the borough.

James secured a 625-count indictment charging five men for participating in the gun smuggling ring, which involved selling dozens of ghost guns, assault weapons, high-capacity magazines and hundreds of rounds of ammunition.